Tesla Model 3 vs Volkswagen ID.4: recalls and problems

Since 2000 the Tesla Model 3 has 36 recalls and 4,407 owner complaints; the Volkswagen ID.4 has 27 recalls and 1,033 complaints. Counts are not adjusted for how many of each were sold.

2026 Tesla Model 3
Tesla Model 3All model years →
2025 Volkswagen Id.4
Volkswagen ID.4All model years →

At a glance

Tesla Model 3Volkswagen ID.4
Recalls3627
Do-not-drive / park-outside recalls04
Owner complaints4,4071,033
Crashes reported462113
Fires reported2215
Injuries reported25873
Most reported problemForward Collision AvoidanceElectrical System

NHTSA data, model years 2000 onward.

Complaints by model year

Tesla Model 3Volkswagen ID.4
2017 Tesla Model 3: 27 complaints20172018 Tesla Model 3: 1,040 complaints20182019 Tesla Model 3: 624 complaints20192020 Tesla Model 3: 455 complaints20202021 Tesla Model 3: 675 complaints2021 Volkswagen ID.4: 341 complaints20212022 Tesla Model 3: 774 complaints2022 Volkswagen ID.4: 137 complaints20222023 Tesla Model 3: 430 complaints2023 Volkswagen ID.4: 469 complaints20232024 Tesla Model 3: 224 complaints2024 Volkswagen ID.4: 54 complaints20242025 Tesla Model 3: 127 complaints2025 Volkswagen ID.4: 31 complaints20252026 Tesla Model 3: 31 complaints2026 Volkswagen ID.4: 1 complaints2026

Every model year

YearModel 3 recallsModel 3 complaintsID.4 recallsID.4 complaints
202613121
20253127231
20245224954
20231243015469
2022187747137
20212267511341
202021455——
201922624——
2018191,040——
20171627——

Tesla Model 3: top problems

Forward Collision Avoidance1,754
Unknown or other707
Vehicle Speed Control638
Electrical System573
Service Brakes572
Steering419

Volkswagen ID.4: top problems

Electrical System521
Unknown or other234
Forward Collision Avoidance154
Vehicle Speed Control124
Structure120
Service Brakes98
Does your car have an open recall?
Recalls apply to specific vehicles. Only a VIN lookup on NHTSA's official site shows whether yours is affected and still unrepaired.
Check your VIN →

Questions

Which has more problems, the Tesla Model 3 or the Volkswagen ID.4?

Since model year 2000 owners have filed 4,407 complaints about the Tesla Model 3 and 1,033 about the Volkswagen ID.4 with NHTSA, so the Volkswagen ID.4 has fewer. These are raw counts: the model that sold more will usually have more complaints, so compare individual model years too.

Which has more recalls, the Tesla Model 3 or the Volkswagen ID.4?

NHTSA lists 36 recall campaigns for the Tesla Model 3 and 27 for the Volkswagen ID.4 since model year 2000.